* = Deceased
1913-1919
| * | Russell T. Kelley | 1913 – 1914 |
| * | Dr. Bruce A. Carey | 1915 |
| * | Stuart H. Lees | 1916 |
| * | W. H. Cooper | 1917 |
| * | Rev. W. H. Sedgewick, D.D. | 1918 |
| * | A. T. Enlow | 1919 |
1920-1929
| * | J. C. Hodge | 1920 |
| * | W. J. Westaway | 1921 |
| * | W. R. Drynan | 1922 |
| * | W. M. Logan | 1923 |
| * | P.W. Gordon, O.B.E. | 1924 |
| * | W. H. Lovering, O.B.E. | 1925 |
| * | L. R. Greene | 1926 |
| * | G. R. Lloyd | 1927 |
| * | F. Kent Hamilton | 1928 |
| * | C. H. Cunningham | 1929 |
1930-1939
| * | H. D. Thomas | 1930 |
| * | John Parkin | 1931 |
| * | Allan R. Lancefield | 1932 |
| * | Lt.-Col. L. H. Millen | 1933 |
| * | R. K. Palmer | 1934 |
| * | Dr. Jas. A. Simpson | 1935 |
| * | Kenneth G. Brown | 1936 |
| * | Gerry Moes | 1937 |
| * | Frank E. Penney | 1938 |
| * | Dr. M. Banker Bates | 1939 |
1940-1949
| * | Dallas W. Bates | 1940 |
| * | Rev. E Crossley Hunter, D.D. | 1941 |
| * | Al J. Park | 1942 |
| * | John I. Flatt | 1942 |
| * | Frank L. Appleford | 1943 |
| * | Norman A. Eager | 1944 |
| * | John J. Enlow | 1945 |
| * | Rev. Donald H. MacLennan | 1946 |
| * | D. R. Briggs | 1947 |
| * | Dr. J. P. Fawcett | 1948 |
| * | Dr. C. E. Vaughan | 1949 |
1950-1959
| * | T. W. Oates | 1950 |
| * | J. L. Coburn | 1951 |
| * | Gordon Mann | 1952 |
| * | Addie Tallman | 1953 |
| * | C. L. Brown | 1954 |
| * | Wilf Carter | 1955 |
| * | R. H. ‘Tug’ Tugman | 1956 |
| * | W. T. Mason | 1957 |
| * | Dr. W. L. Whitelock | 1958 |
| * | Dr. F Basil Bowman | 1959 |
1960-1969
| * | Rev. Dr. A. Lorne Mackay | 1960 |
| * | Jack F. Reesor | 1961 |
| * | Harold K Embree | 1962 |
| * | Percy W. Hankinson | 1963 |
| * | T. A. Rice | 1964 |
| * | Jack H. Moore | 1965 |
| * | John W. Rowley | 1966 |
| * | W. Ross Roger | 1967 |
| * | Dr. Hugo T. Ewart | 1968 |
| * | Alfred U. Oakie | 1969 |
1970-1979
| * | Charlie M. Birkett | 1970 |
| * | Dr. Bob H. Wettlaufer | 1971 |
| * | David R. MacLennan | 1972 |
| * | Dr. J. B. Osbaldeston | 1973 |
| * | Art A. Buckley | 1974 |
| * | Don M. Mann, Q.C. | 1975 |
| * | Tom E. Lamb | 1976 |
| * | Steve M. Fletcher | 1977 |
| * | Bob A. Davey | 1978 |
| * | Bob G. Wilson | 1978 |
| * | Dr. John I. Frid | 1979 |
1980-1989
| * | Bernie W. Gillespie | 1980 |
| Barry D. Nicol | 1981 | |
| * | John F. Shea | 1982 |
| Leo P. Sauve | 1983 | |
| * | Bob G. Forsythe | 1984 |
| * | Vic Hryhorchuk | 1985 |
| * | Bruno K. J. Bragoli | 1986 |
| Reg J. Whynott | 1987 | |
| * | Bob H. L. Patterson | 1988 |
| Rev. Alan M. McPherson | 1989 |
1990-1999
| David E. Seldon | 1990 | |
| * | T. Michael Conoley | 1991 |
| Michael J. Torsney | 1992 | |
| * | Douglas C. McAuley | 1993 |
| * | Len G. Saltmarsh | 1994 |
| * | Harvey R. Smith | 1995 |
| John Logan | 1996 | |
| Brian Fortune | 1997 | |
| Robert N. Leek | 1998 | |
| * | Jill Rumble | 1999 |
2000-2009
| David Simpson | 2000 | |
| Philip D. Winer | 2001 | |
| Anne Bermingham | 2002 | |
| Sandra Stephenson | 2003 | |
| Paul Gibel | 2004 | |
| Keith L. McIntyre | 2005 | |
| Robert Beres | 2006 | |
| John T. Clinton | 2007 | |
| Alex Moroz | 2008 | |
| * | Marie Robbins | 2009 |
2010-2020
| Pearl Wolfe | 2010 | |
| Jim Commerford | 2011 | |
| Bob Monroe – 100th Anniversary | 2012 | |
| * Christopher Cutler – 100th Anniversary | 2013 | |
| Peter Quaglia | 2014 | |
| Rosemary Knetchel | 2015 | |
| Kevin Anstee | 2016 | |
| Brad Spencer | 2017 | |
| Nancy Baker | 2018 | |
| Heather Moroz | 2019 | |
| Alex Moroz | 2020 |
2021-Present
| Alex Moroz | 2021 | |
| Cathi MacDonnell | 2022 | |
| David Elliot | 2023 | |
Hamilton Mountain – Club Presidents
1976 – 1979
| Don Laverty | 1975 – 1976 | |
| Ed Wilson | 1976 – 1977 | |
| Don Harrison | 1977 – 1978 | |
| George Pal | 1978 – 1979 | |
| Bill Downey | 1979 – 1980 |
1980 – 1989
| Frank Stechey | 1980 – 1981 | |
| Bill Festeryga | 1981 – 1982 | |
| Ed Waldes | 1982 – 1983 | |
| Wayne Gerrie | 1983 – 1984 | |
| Gunter Mensch | 1984 – 1985 | |
| Dennis Concordia | 1985 – 1986 | |
| Ed Baker | 1986 – 1987 | |
| Harold Johnson | 1987 – 1988 | |
| Charlie Porteous | 1988 – 1989 | |
| Earl Inglis | 1989 – 1990 |
1990 – 1999
| Bill Traynor | 1990 – 1991 | |
| Tony DiSilvestro | 1991 – 1992 | |
| Bob Packham | 1992 – 1993 | |
| Ron Berdusco | 1993 – 1994 | |
| Colin Millar | 1994 – 1995 | |
| Bill Millar | 1995 – 1996 | |
| Jack Lawler | 1996 – 1997 | |
| Nirmal Takhar | 1997 – 1998 | |
| Phil Slack | 1998 – 1999 | |
| Gene Stodolak | 1999 – 2000 |
2000 – 2009
| David Elliot | 2000 – 2001 | |
| Alana Travis | 2001 – 2002 | |
| Carlo DeLuca | 2002 – 2003 | |
| Santokh Pooni | 2003 – 2004 | |
| Jay Parmar | 2004 – 2005 | |
| Bruno Uggenti | 2005 – 2006 | |
| Terry Anderson | 2006 – 2007 | |
| Vince DeMascio | 2007 – 2008 | |
| Bryan Webber | 2008 – 2009 | |
| Brenda Campbell | 2009 – 2010 |
2010 – 2019 (Merged with Hamilton Rotary Club)
| Vel Balta | 2010 – 2011 | |
| Lynne Lee | 2011 – 2012 | |
| Jay Parmar | 2012 – 2013 | |
| Bruno Uggenti | 2013 – 2014 | |
| Bruno Uggenti | 2014 – 2015 | |
| David Elliot | 2015 – 2016 | |
| Jay Parmar, Bruno Uggenti, Bettina Kelly, Julie Vance | 2016 – 2017 | |
| Judi Emerson | 2017 – 2018 | |
| Judi Emerson | 2018 – 2019 |